Randi Stein: Should try connecting with her tribe

Lum3n/via Pexels

Lum3n/via Pexels Lum3n/via Pexels

Published: 02-03-2024 10:55 AM

I am offended and bewildered by the words of guest columnist Sarena Neyman, who says she is “losing her tribe over Gaza.” [“Losing my tribe over Gaza,” Gazette, Jan. 20]. While I want to hasten to say I too have come to a position that a cease-fire between Hamas and Israel is a necessary step toward justice for the Palestinian people, I have not lost my (Jewish) tribe because “my tribe” has not voiced a shared position over the Israel-Hamas war. I am Jewish, and my Judaism includes many of the things that the writer has discarded — synagogue attendance among them. The Jewish community has many voices, all of which I want to hear. I am delighted Neyman is able to retain a Jewish identity through her committment to “make the world a better place “(TikkunOlam) — an essential component of Jewish practice – but perhaps if she wants emotional access to her tribe again she might actually try going to synagogue, and praying with her tribe, and acting with her tribe, for a better world.

Randi Stein

Amherst

Yesterday's Most Read Articles

Shutesbury Elementary School principal leaving in June after 10 years
Three Amherst Regional Middle School counselors absolved of Title IX offenses
Amherst regional superintendent candidate stresses inclusion, broad expertise
Jena Schwartz: Things I have not said
Next 5-story building cleared to rise in downtown Amherst
Residents seek to balance intersection upgrades with preservation of Sunderland character